Appraisal
GP Appraisal was introduced in 2003 and has been managed and co-ordinated by NIMDTA since April 2006. Appraisal is intended to be a formative process, giving GPs the opportunity to review their performance, chart continuing progress and identify any developmental needs. These developmental needs are collated in a systematic way through the electronic Form 6A and fed into the Continuing Professional Development process.
In managing the appraisal process in Northern Ireland, NIMDTA works in partnership with the DHSSPSNI and the Health & Social Care Board under the guidance of a Central Board of Management, which has representation from the General Practice Committee of the BMA and the Royal College of General Practitioners.
GP Appraisal has the potential to develop the individual doctor and interface with the clinical governance agenda at a practice level to improve the overall quality of GP care across the region.
Timeline for Appraisal
The biggest challenge faced centrally is in distributing appraisals across the whole appraisal year. The first two quarters of the year tend to be light while Appraisers have a heavy workload in the final two quarters. Therefore, in order to try and spread workload further across the coming year the Central Board of Management of GP Appraisal have agreed to implement the following:
12-13 Appraisal Year
- 9 January 2012 - Opening Date for Registration and Declaration Forms
- 30 June 2012 - Deadline for Appraisees who wish to state their preference of: Appraiser, month, date and venue for your appraisal
- After 30 June 2012 - Appraisees who submit Registration and Declaration forms after this date will be allocated
- An Appraiser, based on regional availability (Please note, you may be required to travel to your appraiser, anywhere in the region)
- A particular quarter for your appraisal
- 28 February 2013 - Closing date for Registration and Declaration Forms. Please note forms received after this date will not be accepted.
13-14 Appraisal Year
- 27 January 2013 - Opening Date for Registration and Declaration Forms
- 30 June 2013 - Deadline for Appraisees who wish to state their preference of: Appraiser, month, date and venue for your appraisal
- After 30 June 2013 - Appraisees who submit Registration and Declaration forms after this date will be allocated
- An Appraiser, based on regional availability (Please note, you may be required to travel to your appraiser, anywhere in the region)
- A particular quarter for your appraisal
- 28 February 2014 - Closing date for Registration and Declaration Forms. Please note forms received after this date will not be accepted.
You are advised not to arrange an appraisal with the same Appraiser for more than 3 consecutive years and that you should not book with that Appraiser again for 2 subsequent years.
If you have not undertaken an appraisal within the previous appraisal year due to extenuating circumstances, you are only required to complete one appraisal in the current appraisal year. You do not need to complete two appraisals. See FAQ for further details.
Revalidation
Revalidation will be supportive and focused on raising standards, as Appraisal is now. It is not a mechanism for dealing with the small proportion of doctors who cause concern but it will help identify doctors who need extra support to develop their portfolios in line with the standards set by the GMC and the Royal College of General Practitioners.
For all queries regarding Revalidation please contact:
Caitriona Duggan, Revalidation and Governance Support Officer, HSCB
Tel: 02890 553782
Email: gprevalidation@hscni.net
For all queries regarding Patient and Colleague Feedback please contact:
The Leadership Centre, HSCNI
Tel: 02890 644811
Implementation of Revalidation
- To confirm that licensed doctors practise in accordance with the GMC’s generic standards (relicensure)
- For doctors on the Specialist Register and GP Register, to confirm that they meet the standards appropriate for their specialty (Recertification)
- To identify for further investigation, and remediation, poor practice where local systems are not robust enough to do this or do not exist
When will Revalidation be introduced?
The following Revalidation Implementation Guidelines have been agreed with the DHSSPS.
How will the revalidation process work?
- Licensed doctors will be required to link to a Responsible Officer (RO).
- Licensed doctors will need to maintain a portfoloio of Supporting Information drawn from their practice which demonstrates how they are continuing to meet the principles and values set out in Good Medical Practice Framework for appraisal and revalidation.
- Licensed doctors will be expected to participate in a process of annual appraisal based on their portfolio of supporting information.
- The responsible Officer will make a Recommendation to the GMC about a doctor’s fitness to practise, normally every five years. The recommendation will be based on the outcome of a licensed doctor’s annual appraisals over the course of five years, combined with information drawn from the clinical governance system of the organisation in which the licensed doctor works.
- The GMC’s decision to revalidate a licensed doctor will be informed by the Responsible Officers recommendation.
- Guidelines are available from the GMC regarding how doctors can meet requirements for revalidation in the first cycle.
Revalidation does NOT require a separate revalidation meeting.
The summary of your appraisal history and supporting information (the form 6 signed at appraisal) is sent to the responsible officer (RO) before revalidation.
This summary and any other evidence available through HSCB will be taken into consideration.
A decision will then be made regarding your revalidation.
There is no separate meeting with the RO to trigger this process.
There is an administration team in NIMDTA solely dedicated to GP Appraisal. They are happy to deal with any aspect of appraisal – registration, website enquiries, etc.
- Catherine Hamilton-Cooper - Tel: 028 9040 0032
- Mandy Clements – Tel: 028 9040 0021
- Email: gpappraisal.nimdta@hscni.net
To Register for appraisal, please click here






